What I don’t like about Santa Claus
Posted by Anthony on December 29, 2009
We don’t teach our kids that Santa Claus is ‘real’ but that doesn’t mean I find the idea horrid. See this post for my reasons for not raising my kids to ‘believe in Santa Claus’ and the ironical result that the oldest boy nonetheless… believes in Santa Claus.
Apart from the discussion linked above, this morning I was reminded of another element of the modern day Santa Claus phenom I don’t like.
We celebrated Christmas today as a family because we were traveling over the holiday. In the morning, my oldest- whom I just said believes in Santa despite our efforts- sized up the presents and counted the ones ‘from Santa.’ Some are listed as being from Santa just for his sake.
He didn’t spot any for one of his brothers and announced to the brother, “You must be on Santa’s naughty list because you don’t have any presents from him.” I confronted him immediately on this and then told his brother (who was beginning to tear up) that mommy and daddy were Santa Claus but, “Shhhhh, your brother doesn’t know that yet.” (This was said in the hearing of the eldest.)
While I like the idea of celebrating God’s gift to humanity by giving gifts to each other, the Santa Claus mythology has a twist that I just don’t appreciate: On Christmas we celebrate God’s free gift to a very naughty humanity that did nothing to deserve it and can do nothing to cause God to withhold it, but Santa Claus only gives his gifts to those who are not on his ‘naughty list.’
This is devilish twist of God’s grace that just bothers me and one more reason why we don’t tell our kids that Santa Claus is ‘real.’ Granted, this devilish twist doesn’t have to be there… parents could counter act it. I’m not here judging anyone, I’m just making an observation.



























