subscribe to the RSS Feed

Monday, September 6, 2010

    This ministry needs your financial support! Donate now!

    Click Here to Read my Blog | My ChristianPost Blog Entries
    Anthony Horvath's Facebook profile
    Sign up for Apologetics Newsletter
    Anthony's Faith Statement.
    Discussion Forum
    Anthony in the media
    Video Ministry Sntjohnny Youtube Apologetics Ministry
    (And on Youtube...)
    A brief Introduction:

    While studying to be a pastor in college I abandoned my faith. In fact, I abandoned everything I thought I believed and rebuilt.

    To my own surprise at the time, I found that Christianity was much stronger than I had thought. As I rebuilt my belief system, I realized that there needed to be people out there responding to the questions people have. I had them myself. So, while not continuing on to be a pastor, I have focused on educating people about what Christianity is all about and responding to the various charges and accusations made against it.

    There are some obvious challenges to being successful in that capacity, but a big part of it consists not in arguing with atheists and skeptics, but rather in providing Christians with accurate information in the first place to prevent them from leaving the faith in the first place.

    Questioning is a very normal and natural part of growing up, and I am convinced that it is not wrong to ask questions of God at any age. God doesn't strike people down. On the other hand, if people are going to reject Christianity, it is my aim to at least make sure they reject the real Christianity and not a false view of it. Also, much heartache can be avoided by educating Christians properly to begin with. My experience has helped me... but it was unnecessary.

    Paul said that some plant, some water, and others reap the increase. My job is to go out into the land and move rocks- or break them if necessary- till the land, and struggle through knee deep fertilizer... all in the effort to allow those who come later to plant, water, and reap the harvest. I look forward to the prospects of either serving you as someone who needs to haul rocks out of the field, or as someone who can look at the field, detect problems, and help farmers more effectively plant, water, and reap.

    Here Begins my Blog

This ministry needs your financial support! Donate now!

C.S. Lewis on Universal Health Care and the Love of Some

Posted by Anthony on April 28, 2010

I was reading CS Lewis’s The Four Loves and came across the quote below.  Obviously, Lewis is not specifically addressing universal health care or liberalism or the question of using the government to administer love.  Even Christians can be found thinking that it is a noble expression of a loving society to have the government do the loving… and this with no apparent thought to the actual effect that this ‘loving’ will have on the people ‘loved’ and the attitude it fuels in the people-government doing the ‘loving.’  The most important thing seems to be that, well, people’s intentions are good, and it’s better to do something rather than nothing.  Here is the quote:

This [is] Gift-love, but one that needs to give; therefore needs to be needed.  But the proper aim of giving is to put the recipient in a state where he no longer needs our gift.  We feed children in order that they may soon be able to feed themselves; we teach them in order that they may soon not need our teaching.  Thus a heavy task is laid upon this Gift-love.  It must work towards its own abdication.  We must aim at making ourselves superfluous.  The hour when we can say “They need me no longer” shall be our reward.  But the instinct, simply in its own nature, has no power to fulfil this law.  The instinct desires the good of its object, but not simply;  only the good it can itself give.  A much higher love- a love which desires the good of the object as such, from whatever source that good comes- must step in and help or tame the instinct before it can make the abdication.  And of course it often does.  But where it does not, the ravenous need to be needed will gratify itself either by keeping its objects needy or by inventing for them imaginary needs.  It will do this all the more ruthlessly because it thinks (in one sense truly) that it is a Gift-love and therefore regards itself as “unselfish.”  (pgs 50-51)

Some discussion.

In the conversations I found myself in objecting to health care, I heard repeatedly how selfish I was being.  In the comments on blog entries I saw the same thing.  “If you really loved people you would support this bill.  You’re just selfish.  You just don’t want to pay taxes.”

I oppose universal health care, especially when put forward on secular grounds, precisely because I do love people.  I do not believe it is in the best interest of most people in either the short term or long term.  The Lewis quote above alludes to some reasons why. Read the rest of the entry… »

  • Share/Bookmark